I agree. This is much like my lineup last year that won, and I say better even. Doesn't jump off the page but it's hard to find a real fault either. With a bit of good fotune watching over your health, I'd feel good predicting a top half finish at very least.
To compare, I had:
Piazza, Helton, B Harris, Zimmerman, Renteria, Byrnes, Griffey, G Anderson, Ellsbury, Thome, B Butler
Peavy, Blanton, Francis, Bonderman, Lily, Byrd, Livan, Putz, Saito, Corpas, K Gregg
Hardly scary. With one underachiever it could all tumble, but didn't and was good enough for $250
Just keep an eye out for that gem of a closer that comes up every year and sit back and enjoy.