Who Has More Value to Your Team??

[acsguitar]

It depends on the league. In a really balanced league with K's I'd take the Middle reliever. IF holds come into play i'd take him too

[Yoda]

i like the fact you pointed out that that there are only 60 open OF spots in the MLB. we use 48 OF spots. so i would put willingham on the lower tier of those 48 spots. also we do have 2 RP spots, but we also use a couple SP spots along with a couple general P spots that can be used for any type of RP or SP. so putting marmol there along with a couple RPs would be nice. so with that info, would you rather have a lower 4th OF with some upside or a guy like marmol that can out up some big numbers and have a chance to become your 3rd RP??

This is probably not the right forum to be asking these questions.

That being said, I don't put as much emphasis on MRs at the draft since dominant new ones always emerge every year from nowhere. Willingham is not sexy and probably is on the lower tier of your 48 OF spots but he has a definite role and will be playing everyday.