3. Brooks Robinson-1975: 3B: .201/.267/.274, 6 HR, OPS(plus) 58, VORP -20.7, 6 Win Shares.
Robinson was still a good player in 1974, but boy did he drop off quickly in 1975. Earl Weaver must have been in a difficult position, and certainly felt pressure to play Brooks because of his stature. But there is no way Robinson should have gotten 502 plate appearances while the Orioles were in a playoff hunt. Unfortunately, Robinson hung on for two more terrible years as a part-time player before finally retiring in 1977.
5. Rey Ordonez-1998: SS: .246/.278/.299, 1 HR, OPS(plus) 53, VORP -14.5, 9 Win Shares.
Ordonez is probably the most over-rated and over-hyped player of my lifetime. Great defense no doubt, but having Rey batting 8th was like having two pitchers batting back to back. The Mets finished two games behind the Cubs for the Wild Card in 1998. If you go by VORP, the Mets could have employed a shortstop just barely better than a Triple A player and tied the Cubs.
THE ENTIRE LIST