1. Hudson (most consistant)
2. Mulder (can throw the most innings and gets wins, but injury concern)
3. Zito (K rate declining, and is the most inconsistant of the 3)
Hudson is the obvious #1, he's just plain awesome. Mulder and Zito are pretty much the same player stats wise. Personally, I'll take Mulder who has proven he can win games without getting a lot of K's, unlike Zito.
What do you mean unlike Zito? Last 3 years Zito has 54 wins, Mulder 55, Hudson 49.
3 year whips
Mulder 1.16
Hudson 1.18
Zito 1.18
3 year eras
Hudson 3.02
Zito 3.17
Mulder 3.36
K rate
Mulder 6.2
Hudson 6.1
Zito 5.7
Why is Hudson considered the easy #1? I still like Zito. I'm stubborn.
Zito
Hudson
Mulder
Smells Like Teen Spirit
HOOTIE
Hall of Fame Hero
Posts: 14818
(Past Year: 539)
Joined: 12 Jan 2003
Bases this season: 4,242
Home Cafe: Baseball
Location: Pearl Jam country, right next door to Nirvana, Soundgarden, and Alice in Chains.
Hudson is the obvious #1, he's just plain awesome. Mulder and Zito are pretty much the same player stats wise. Personally, I'll take Mulder who has proven he can win games without getting a lot of K's, unlike Zito.
What do you mean unlike Zito? Last 3 years Zito has 54 wins, Mulder 55, Hudson 49.
3 year whips
Mulder 1.16 Hudson 1.18 Zito 1.18
3 year eras
Hudson 3.02 Zito 3.17 Mulder 3.36
K rate
Mulder 6.2 Hudson 6.1 Zito 5.7
Why is Hudson considered the easy #1? I still like Zito. I'm stubborn.
Zito Hudson Mulder
Zito's career K/9 rate is still higer then Hudson and Mulder
Hudson is the obvious #1, he's just plain awesome. Mulder and Zito are pretty much the same player stats wise. Personally, I'll take Mulder who has proven he can win games without getting a lot of K's, unlike Zito.
What do you mean unlike Zito? Last 3 years Zito has 54 wins, Mulder 55, Hudson 49.
3 year whips
Mulder 1.16 Hudson 1.18 Zito 1.18
3 year eras
Hudson 3.02 Zito 3.17 Mulder 3.36
K rate
Mulder 6.2 Hudson 6.1 Zito 5.7
Why is Hudson considered the easy #1? I still like Zito. I'm stubborn.
Zito Hudson Mulder
I usually agree with Hootie but this time I'm the anti-Hootie.
RynMan wrote:Man, they are all cy young quality pitchers.
Id say Hudson Mulder Zito
But dam....these guys are soo close its not funny. Nowhere in baseball do you have three guys on your staff that you have soo much trouble ranking.
Well it's easier for me to rank these 3 than say the bottom half of the Reds staff.
Claussen Haynes Harang Acevedo
Now that's tough.
i stand corrected! how embarassing....
LOL
My rankings on these 3 change every day. Honestly, given the background inconsistency in pitching stats year to year, I don't think there's a good way to differentiate between the three for fantasy purposes. Take whichever and as many of the 3 you can get and smile.
"The game has a cleanness. If you do a good job, the numbers say so. You don't have to ask anyone or play politics. You don't have to wait for the reviews." - Sandy Koufax
Cafe Home
Fantasy Football
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by ferris182 » Mon Feb 16, 2004 12:36 pm 
