Moustakas vs Pedro Alvarez (undrafted)

[Jackalope]

How would you rate these two (Moustakas / Alvarez / Smoak?)

[Koby Schellenger]

Alvarez is tops for sure. I'd personally take Smoak ahead of Moustakas at the moment because I'm a big fan of taking the lower risk players. Moustakas top level of competition is 40 some at-bats in rookie ball. I'll take Smoak's college experience suggesting a lower risk over Moustakas potential (saying nothing about Smoak's potential).

[Jackalope]

thanks for the response...

What is Smoak's status? Drafted (signed)? signing next season?

[Koby Schellenger]

thanks for the response...

What is Smoak's status? Drafted (signed)? signing next season?

Entering his Junior season at South Carolina. Will be drafted this June. Probably will sign.

[Grounded Polo]

Definitely Alvarez over Moustakas because their ceiling is basically the same but Alvarez will be up at least a year earlier. I'd probably give Moustakas the nod over Smoak right now because Moose has more potential and plays a premium position (for now).

[High Heater]

i'd rank them

Alvarez, Moustakas, Smoak

both now and potential.

[05worldserieschamps]

i'd rank them

Alvarez, Moustakas, Smoak

both now and potential.

yeah, same here. Ive seen Alvarez play in person on more than one occasion and he is really something. Guy can flat out hit.

[deerayfan072]

i'd rank them

Alvarez, Moustakas, Smoak

both now and potential.

Totally agree, which is why I am praying the Rays take Alvarez number 1

[High Heater]

i can see the Rays going Matusz actualy imo.... just a hunch even with all those loaded arms.

[deerayfan072]

i can see the Rays going Matusz actualy imo.... just a hunch even with all those loaded arms.

I do too. Him or Crow