help please

[triple3play]

i know these guys arent really minor leaguers anymore, but who has the highest ceiling out of Ellsbury, Ethier, and Kemp....who would you most want on your FB team

[Seattle Squirrels]

Kemp and Kemp, very easily.

Kemp has all the tools to be a star in the league. He has shown good power, good speed, and an ability to hit the ball well at the Major League level.

I honestly dont understand what the commotion about Ellsbury is, beside him being an employee of the Boston Red Sox.

[Koby Schellenger]

Kemp
Ethier



Ellsbury


Go with Kemp for sure. Ethier is close. Ignore 3-cat Ellsbury if you can get either of the other two.

[eviljoshing]

Well not to sound redoundant but Kemp by a fair amount.

[J35J]

hhmmm....interesting. While Ellsbury has the lowest ceiling of the three, the guy I'd most rather have for '08 is....Ellsbury!

[BigLeagueFutures]

Kemp has the highest upside, surely the Dodgers will give him a full time job SOON!!

[cardinal1975]

Kemp has the most potential
Ellsbury has the best chance of reaching his potential
Ethier is a .280 hitter that may hit 17-23hr someday and is not good enough to play as a corner OF...not much upside whatsoever. He is a Casey Blake type player....the kind of guy who if he is your starter the team continually tries to upgrade.

[AEMRICH]

Kemp- this guy is going to be a top 20 OF once he gets a full time job

[rederic101]

hhmmm....interesting. While Ellsbury has the lowest ceiling of the three, the guy I'd most rather have for '08 is....Ellsbury!

ya i agree in 08 i would take Ellsbury but the player with the most up side is easily kemp if he ever is allowed to play.

[kab21]

Kemp has the most potential
Ellsbury has the best chance of reaching his potential
Ethier is a .280 hitter that may hit 17-23hr someday and is not good enough to play as a corner OF...not much upside whatsoever. He is a Casey Blake type player....the kind of guy who if he is your starter the team continually tries to upgrade.

These are my thoughts. Ellsbury is a nice player, but doesn't have the potential that Kemp has. Ethier doesn't excite me, Casey Blake is a nice comparison.