Help Ranking....

[nbb23]

How would you rank these prospects:

J. Mcgee
J. Vitters
M. Moustakas
J. Tabata
R. Porcello

Who has the most potential out of the group?

[mikeprovri]

I would have to go:

J. Mcgee
R. Porcello
M. Moustakas
J. Vitters
J. Tabata

Flip-flop Porcello/Moustakas and I wouldn't argue much.

[auclairkeithbc]

I would have to go:

J. Mcgee
R. Porcello
M. Moustakas
J. Vitters
J. Tabata

Flip-flop Porcello/Moustakas and I wouldn't argue much.

I agree with this ranking, and I would flip Porcello and Moustakas.

[BigLeagueFutures]

McGee
Porcello
Moustakas
Vitters
Tabata

[rhd]

My order:

- McGee (#26)
- Moustakas (#34)
- Porcello (#36)
- Vitters (#45)
- Tabata (#47)

Everyone here so far seems to rank them similarly.

Hard to be too confident about the rank of the middle 3 tho, since they're all 18-19 y/o and havent played much.

[Seattle Squirrels]

Top prospects now:

1. McGee
2. Porcello
3. Moustakas
4. Vitters
5. Tabata

Potential Only:

1. Porcello
2. Moustakas
3. McGee
4. Tabata
5. Vitters

What I expect for their careers:

1. Porcello
2. McGee
3. Moustakas
4. Vitters
5. Tabata

[Omaha Red Sox]

I'd go:

McGee
Porcello
Moustakas
Vitters
Tabata

[DevilDriver]

J. Mcgee
R. Porcello
M. Moustakas
J. Tabata
J. Vitters

[J35J]

J. Mcgee
R. Porcello
M. Moustakas
J. Tabata
J. Vitters

I like this list....I wouldn't complain with Vitters over Tabata but who freakin knows....they're 3-4 years away from contributing much of anything so it all could change.

[High Heater]

1. Porcello
2. Moustakas
3. McGee
4. Tabata
5. Vitters


Porcello's potential is too much to pass up on, think kershaw with more imo. Mous could be a good middle order bat and he could stay at 2B or slide to 2B in the future.