Cabrera vs Heyward vs Vitters vs Porcello

[Philly_05]

I have 5 players for 2 spots. I need to setup my keepers by the 15th of November. I'm torn on keeping the kid hitters vs keeping my high end SP. Though I get teased with the TINSTAAPP. I can work it one of three ways.

I can keep Asdrubal Cabrera and one of Jason Heyward, Josh Vitters, and Rick Porcello.

I can keep one of Jason Heyward or Josh Vitters with Rick Porcello

I can keep Jason Heyward and Josh Vitters

My other keepers that I have set for the minors are Evan Longoria, Shane Victorino, and Yovani Gallardo. In a way I lucked into Victorino being eligible for my minors because of injury. But which set would you prefer i'm leaning toward the hitter hitter but not sold totally on this idea yet. An Nick Adenhart seems like a after thought with what I have above him.

[auclairkeithbc]

how is that question different from asking which two would we take?

i would take porcello and heyward.

[bigken117]

so you couldn't keep Vitters with Porcello? Weird...

I'd keep Heyward and Porcello given the options.

[auclairkeithbc]

so you couldn't keep Vitters with Porcello? Weird...

I'd keep Heyward and Porcello given the options.

yes, he can keep any combination.

[DevilDriver]

Vitters and Porcello

[BigLeagueFutures]

I'd go w/ Porcello and Vitters, but it'll be tough to toss Heyward back.