CAFE AL ROTY: OFFICIAL (UNOFFICIAL) CAFE VOTE

[thedude]

Dustin walks away with it, even without Delmon's antics.

Pedroia EQA: .276 FRAR: 25 OPS+: 115
Young EQA: .251 FRAR: 6 OPS+: 88
Willits EQA: .268 FRAR: 18 OPS+ 101

Not even close.

[Yoda]

Pedroia will probably win it but I think he is going to be a huge bust next year.

[Field]

Pedroia will probably win it but I think he is going to be a huge bust next year.

Fantasy bust or real-life bust or both?

The kid is a gamer, I have a hard time seeing him being a bust for the Bo-Sox next year provided he stays healthy. He has hit at every single level in the minors after an intial adjustment period. He may be undersized, but I see him being the sox 2B for a while.

[DbacksRback]

dice k wasnt even that great considering the hype hes like a #3 on a rotation compared to the # 1 so many thought. its funny how hes struggling to win ROY when he was thought of as a possible CY..... i went with young

[theclefe]

Shame Jeremy Guthrie didn't make the list. He had a very good rookie year. Better than Bannister in everything except wins.

[acsguitar]

Shame Jeremy Guthrie didn't make the list. He had a very good rookie year. Better than Bannister in everything except wins.

I didn't really spend much time on this

[Omaha Red Sox]

Young's 93 RBIs jump out at me, but then Pedroia's .317 BA as a 2B help me make my decision. If Young had swiped a few more bags he'd be my vote easily.

[theclefe]

Shame Jeremy Guthrie didn't make the list. He had a very good rookie year. Better than Bannister in everything except wins.

I didn't really spend much time on this

No worries. Don't think he'd win it anyway.

[jlm53089]

the reason dustin is going to win it is because he plays in boston.

and i told you all that dice-k would not live up to the hype.

and my vote is for delmon. more rbis. good avg. and played in almost every game but the last one while dustin missed 25 games

[thedude]

the reason dustin is going to win it is because he plays in boston.

and i told you all that dice-k would not live up to the hype.

and my vote is for delmon. more rbis. good avg. and played in almost every game but the last one while dustin missed 25 games

Last time i checked TB sports writers got as many votes as the boston ones.