Tulo's rank among SS in 08

[Mike Fetters]

Hardy isn't even close to a Top 10 SS. Low average, no steals and he will not come close to his HR total this season in 2008.

I would rank Tulo 7th for 2008.

[dclark0699]

1. Hanley
2. Reyes
3. Rollins
4. Tulo


I think his numbers will at least slightly improve next year. Hitting toward the top of the Rockies lineup is not a bad thing at all. I think Tulo profiles more as a 3 or 5 hitter for the future...when either Helton or Atkins part with the team.

[dissent]

1. Hanley
2. Reyes
3. Rollins
4. Tulo

I agree with this as far as rankings, but I think his ADP will be lower next year. Jeter, Tejada and maybe Young will still be taken over him. I'll probably target him around the 6-8th round.

[Chadgo5]

Is Tulo a keeper in a 13 team, 7 keeper per team, league... at $1?

My other keeper possibilities are:
C - Mauer
1B - Konerko
2B - Roberts
3B - Wright
OF - Hunter
OF - Markakis
SP - Peavy
SP - Oswalt

[dclark0699]

Is Tulo a keeper in a 13 team, 7 keeper per team, league... at $1?

My other keeper possibilities are:
C - Mauer
1B - Konerko
2B - Roberts
3B - Wright
OF - Hunter
OF - Markakis
SP - Peavy
SP - Oswalt

I'd probbaly keep him over Konerko, Hunter, Markakis and Oswalt.

[djxskillz]

u guys forgot about edgar

[J35J]

u guys forgot about edgar

I don't think anyone is forgetting Edgar.....

[djxskillz]

how can u leave edgar out? He has had an amazing season until he went on the DL twice. I remember before he went on the DL he like the 5th best SS according to yahoo rankings. Please don't even say JJ hardy should be a "top" SS. He is on the waiver wire in my league.

[J35J]

how can u leave edgar out? He has had an amazing season until he went on the DL twice. I remember before he went on the DL he like the 5th best SS according to yahoo rankings. Please don't even say JJ hardy should be a "top" SS. He is on the waiver wire in my league.

I spoke too soon.....I was thinking of the last few posts (top 4-5 SS posts) when you commented on Edgar. If you're talking about the OP top 10 or so then yeah I think Edgar falls in there somewhere.

Misunderstood...my fault!

[J35J]

With that said, I think Edgar has just as good of a shot to hit .275 as he does .330 next year....though he'll likely fall right in the middle somewhere (.290-.300) I also think he'll be just a bit overrated in next years drafts because of his good avg this year. He won't be the 5th best SS next year....he'll likely border on the top 10. I haven't looked to deep into yet though to say for sure.