KDOGG wrote:I realize Pelfrey has already reached the majors but which one do you think has the higher ceiling?
I have to go with McGee for higher ceiling. McGees ceiling is probably as a very good #2 pushing #1 status where as Pelfrey ranks around a 3 or so. Now when you rank the chances of each reaching their ceiling, then I think Pelfrey has a much higher chance of reaching his ceiling as McGee could end becoming a LOOGY just as much as he could the #2. Pelfrey does have the added bonus of being in the National League as well.
As far as whom to pickup, I would probably go with McGee for the higher ceiling if they are players that can be stuck in a farm system in your league.