why is it?

[who]

that people have maggs ahead of manny in rankings?

[NZF]

Still thinking 2002

[kentx12]

I dont. I have Manny ranked just ahead of Maggs.

[mocabeenow]

i will never have to rank Magg's because he will always be kept by somebody in my league. Got to trade to get him!
~Moc

[GSes]

I agree. And as I always say Why is it everyone ranks Mags and Manny ahead of Sheffield. I believe Sheffield is a great late first round pick. Sheff is going from one explosive lineup to another and some will say he is going to a better pitcher's park, well Sheff had some monster years in LA also. I think Sheffield should be a first rounder, Manny a late first rounder/early second. and Mags should be a mid - late 2nd rounder.

Sheff
Manny
Mags

[baseball genius]

I don't think Mags will ever fall all the way to the late second round. But I would rank em Sheff, Manny, Mags.

[Erboes]

I think Ordonez is usually ahead of Ramirez because of the steals and the fact he rarely misses any games. With Sheffield I think it's because Sheffield misses too many games as well. If all three were 160 games a years players it may be Sheffield, Ramirez, then Ordonez.

[slowkidz]

hmmm...so far in one of my drafts the only one of the three to be drafted is Manny...and he went in the early 2nd round. Sheff and Mags are still available and the 2nd rnd is almost done, 4 picks are left....and one of them is mine!!

[prodpaul]

No way. Manny is above Maggs on my board. I may be crazy and a homer but I have Juan Gone over maggs...uh oh here comes the bashing now..

[trevisc]

maybe because Manny is a bit of an injury risk (hamstrings) OR maybe because Maggs will still get you double digit steals. I have them side by side in my mind but I would take Maggs over Manny because Manny hasn't ever played over 154 games in a season.