byfrcp wrote:Harden anybody???
Not even close. Way too unreliable to be near the top ten. I think Young and Haren are generally too high on these lists. I don't think Maine should be anywhere near the top ten, even in a keeper. If we're talking re-draft, Smoltz needs more credit. I'd put Bonderman toward the bottom or in the honorable mention category.
Also, it's funny how a half season of Haren and Oswalt have completely reversed their respective values. In fact, I don't think I've seen Oswalt on a list yet. He's got quite the history to just be writing him off.