So what is salty's value now?

[nofsk]

I got pudge playing at catcher right now. Whats his value relative to saltys?

[CBMGreatOne]

I got pudge playing at catcher right now. Whats his value relative to saltys?

Pudge is a guy I probably wouldn't drop for Salty just yet. His upside is much lower, but he has been a reliable option and, generally speaking, won't hurt you.

If you have a roster spot, I'd consider dropping someone else for him though, and seeing how things go for the next couple of weeks.

My inclination is that Salty will produce about equal to Pudge the rest of the way, though with the potential for much more power, but a lower floor. This one is a toss up.

[BitterDodgerFan]

the salty manlove is getting a bit extreme here at the cafe...i'd wait until he starts mashing consistently to drop any of the top 10 catchers.

[CBMGreatOne]

the salty manlove is getting a bit extreme here at the cafe...i'd wait until he starts mashing consistently to drop any of the top 10 catchers.

Ok fine, list your top 10, and I'll show why one of them belongs out. There doesn't have to be extreme manlove to warrant a top 10 spot at catcher. It's a terribly thin position right now. Not sure why there'd be anything but optimism at this point. He didn't get consistent at bats in Atlanta. He will now. Your above position will be proven conclusively wrong in time.

[tecmobowl12]

Your above position will be proven conclusively wrong in time.

classic