Fantasy Baseball Cafe Forums

by **nemergoot** » Sun Jul 29, 2007 10:49 pm

ok here is the information on the league- its a yahoo dynasty league keep all 5x5 head to head and there are 18 teams here are the rosters

team 1- is currently in 1st place and is up by 5 games to 2nd place and is currently beating second place 8-2 this week

C- Russel Martin
1b- Albert Pujols
2b Kaz Matsui
3b Aramis Ramirez
SS Hanley Ramirez
OF- Matt Holliday
OF- Andruw Jones
OF-Milton Bradely
Util-Akinori Iwamura
Util Paul Konerko
Bnch-evan Longoria
Bnch-Andy Laroche
DL- Marcus Thames
DL- Howie Kendrick

Sp- Yovani Gallardo
SP Daniel Cabrera
Sp- Jered Weaver
Sp joe saunders
Sp Matt Garza
Rp- Chad Billingsley
Rp Jonathan Broxton
Rp Hideki Okajima
Bn- Roy Oswalt
BN tim lincecum
Bn Dave Bush
Bn Tom Gorzelanny
Dl Akinori Otsuka

Team 2- is currently in 15 place and is out of first by more that 30 games here is the roster

C- Jason Varitek
1B- Jeff Kent
2b- Mark Grudzielanek
3B edwin Encarnacion
SS Carlos Guillen
OF Carlos Beltran
Of Johnny Damon
OF Carlos Lee
Util-Jason Bartlett
Util-Austin Kearns
Bn Bobby Crosby
BN chris Burke
Bn Carlos Ruiz
Bn Craig Monroe
Bn Gerald Laird

Sp Dan Haren
Sp Barry Zito
Sp Zach Greinke
Sp Nate Robertson
Sp Ted Lilly
Rp Todd Jones
RP aaron Heilman
Rp Trevor Hoffman
Rp Octavio Dotel
Rp yusmeiro Petit
DL Kerry Wood
Dl francisco Liriano

alright the trade was

Team 1 gets
Carlos Beltran

Team 2 gets
Paul Konerko
Milton Bradely

my argument in this trade is that team 1 just gets stronger then dont need Konerko in the first place and then they get there outfield strong with a 20-20 maybe 30-30 guy with beltran i just find this trade unfair and i wanted to know what you guys think

by **luckygehrig** » Sun Jul 29, 2007 11:39 pm

I don't think it's vetoable.

by **phillyphan12** » Sun Jul 29, 2007 11:48 pm

me niether

by **StoneColdBrown** » Mon Jul 30, 2007 1:56 pm

This is why I believe trades should be freely allowed (collusion excepted). It's really not even unfair. That shouldn't even be brought to a veto table. Konerko will probably outperform Beltran the rest of the way (minus bags, of course).

by **CBMGreatOne** » Mon Jul 30, 2007 3:18 pm

StoneColdBrown wrote:This is why I believe trades should be freely allowed (collusion excepted). It's really not even unfair. That shouldn't even be brought to a veto table. Konerko will probably outperform Beltran the rest of the way (minus bags, of course).

This trade is fair, but this isn't an example of why trades should be allowed except for collusion. It's just a fair trade, so his question is an easy one to answer.