I can't see how anyone can complain about Reyes' stats. He has hit over .300 for the year, an OBP around .380, 49SB's, 7HR's, 41RBI's, etc. He's doing exactly what everyone who drafted him with their first round pick expected him to do.
In my opinion, Pujols has been the bigger disappointment, not to mention the slew of other 1st and 2nd round underachievers like Beltran, Berkman, Crawford, A. Jones, Wells, Hafner, etc.
When Reyes finishes the year with .300 12HR's 70RBI's 75SB's and 110R's, you won't hear me complaining.