Matt Holiday

[DevilDriver]

As a Holliday owner, I value him over Pujols right now

That's crazy

Do you base player value entirely off of first half stats?

No but Holliday had a great year last year too.

he wasn't as good as Pujols

[A Fleshner Fantasy]

That's crazy

Do you base player value entirely off of first half stats?

No but Holliday had a great year last year too.

he wasn't as good as Pujols

In my defense, I have 4 injured OF and 2 top 10 healthy 1B.

[acsguitar]

No but Holliday had a great year last year too.

he wasn't as good as Pujols

You neglected to include the rest of that quote



This part
"But yea I'd trade Holliday for Pujols any day and I love Holliday long time"

[Secret Avatar]

This is nutty. I've got a man-crush on Holliday and think he's a legitimate top-10 (or at least top-15) fantasy player, but if someone offered me Pujols I wouldn't hestitate to pull the trigger.

BTW, Holliday was 4-4 today with 4 runs, 2 RBI, and a HR. Hope this is the end of his slump.

[RynMan]

I still don't think he hits over .320 to end the season.

[rotoquest]

I still don't think he hits over .320 to end the season.

If he does look for him to be a 1st round draft choice next year in a standard 12 team league. His peripheral stats with a .320+ avg the rest of the year will be outstanding.

[DevilDriver]

You neglected to include the rest of that quote



This part
"But yea I'd trade Holliday for Pujols any day and I love Holliday long time"

I agree with you on that, but I was only responding to the part I quoted.

[RynMan]

I still don't think he hits over .320 to end the season.

If he does look for him to be a 1st round draft choice next year in a standard 12 team league. His peripheral stats with a .320+ avg the rest of the year will be outstanding.

Yeah, I agree. He will find his way into the first round.

[markj11]

I still don't think he hits over .320 to end the season.

If he does look for him to be a 1st round draft choice next year in a standard 12 team league. His peripheral stats with a .320+ avg the rest of the year will be outstanding.

Yeah, I agree. He will find his way into the first round.

Umm, didn't he do that last year? Actually, he isn't even on pace with his last years numbers.

[rjforlife]

[/quote]

Umm, didn't he do that last year? Actually, he isn't even on pace with his last years numbers.[/quote]

He was a top 10 earner last season. People didnt take him in the first because it was only his first full season. If he repeats last season or is negligbly close to those numbers, he will go 1st round.