Thanks to everyone for your advice so far. I am really having a tough time here. I think I have changed my mind a hundred times already.
I think I'm leaning towards AROD right now. Although Gagne was out of this world last year, and is certainly the top closer this year, I feel confident that I can still pick up a Wagner, Rivera, Foluke with a later pick (I'm hoping round 3).
In a weekly points league I don't think you can pass up a guy who will automatically put up at least 40 points a week, where as Gagne's numbers will fluctuate more dependent on save opportunities and will. Last year I had Gagne, and he had 60 point weeks and 15 point weeks.
I almost have myself convinced but I would love to hear more from the experts
Thanks agian for the help so far