2007 ALL-STAR BREAK SIG CONTEST - THE VOTE!

[Snakes Gould]

I is easily the best sig graphically, imo.

A-7
B-0
C-1
D-7
E-5
F-1
G-1
H-0
I-11
J-0
K-0
L-1
M-1
N-6

im not sure if this is the time or place for this, but ill go on anyway...

i think i is great, and you are definitely free to vote how you like, but in what ways do you see i as far and away better than d? i think they're both great and could see an argument for either but easily?

[ukrneal]

im not sure if this is the time or place for this, but ill go on anyway...

i think i is great, and you are definitely free to vote how you like, but in what ways do you see i as far and away better than d? i think they're both great and could see an argument for either but easily?

I agree as only 11 out of 41 votes have gone to it (not even 30%), which means 30 people disagreed with his assessment. I also think it takes away from the great job all the artists have done here. Each should be commended. I was impressed by all of them and had difficulty narrowing my selection down to one.

[Danger]

Looks like I is probably going to win so I guess I'll cast my vote.

A-7
B-0
C-1
D-8
E-5
F-1
G-1
H-0
I-11
J-0
K-0
L-1
M-1
N-6

All the sigs are very creative but D stood out to me immediately. I thought it would come down to I and D anyways but with D running away with it.

[Simulacrum]

A-7
B-0
C-1
D-8
E-5
F-2
G-1
H-0
I-11
J-0
K-0
L-1
M-1
N-6

Only one other person likes F the best?? I thought it was far and away the best sig up there.

And a big tip of the cap to "G" as well.

[Snakes Gould]

Only one other person likes F the best?? I thought it was far and away the best sig up there.

And a big tip of the cap to "G" as well.

thanks

[DevilDriver]

I is easily the best sig graphically, imo.

A-7
B-0
C-1
D-7
E-5
F-1
G-1
H-0
I-11
J-0
K-0
L-1
M-1
N-6

im not sure if this is the time or place for this, but ill go on anyway...

i think i is great, and you are definitely free to vote how you like, but in what ways do you see i as far and away better than d? i think they're both great and could see an argument for either but easily?

Yes, easily. IMO, the text, bg, render effects, and lighting on I are better than D's. And that's not taking anything away from D, which is a great sig. It's just that I think that I is an even better sig and the best one here.

[DevilDriver]

im not sure if this is the time or place for this, but ill go on anyway...

i think i is great, and you are definitely free to vote how you like, but in what ways do you see i as far and away better than d? i think they're both great and could see an argument for either but easily?

I agree as only 11 out of 41 votes have gone to it (not even 30%), which means 30 people disagreed with his assessment. I also think it takes away from the great job all the artists have done here. Each should be commended. I was impressed by all of them and had difficulty narrowing my selection down to one.

First of all, I don't understand your point in stating the number of people who disagreed with me. Whichever sig you voted for, over 30 people disagreed with you too! I definitely did not intend to take away from any of the other sigs. Hell, one of them is mine. I also was impressed by all of them, but one of them was clearly the best in my eyes. I don't see what's so wrong about that.

[ukrneal]

im not sure if this is the time or place for this, but ill go on anyway...

i think i is great, and you are definitely free to vote how you like, but in what ways do you see i as far and away better than d? i think they're both great and could see an argument for either but easily?

I agree as only 11 out of 41 votes have gone to it (not even 30%), which means 30 people disagreed with his assessment. I also think it takes away from the great job all the artists have done here. Each should be commended. I was impressed by all of them and had difficulty narrowing my selection down to one.

First of all, I don't understand your point in stating the number of people who disagreed with me. Whichever sig you voted for, over 30 people disagreed with you too! I definitely did not intend to take away from any of the other sigs. Hell, one of them is mine. I also was impressed by all of them, but one of them was clearly the best in my eyes. I don't see what's so wrong about that.

By saying 'clearly' and 'easily', you are putting down the others. I don't think you mean to imply it, but you are. If you had just said it was 'an easy decision for me', I would not have looked twice.

[Snakes Gould]

i didnt reply to you because i thought you were putting other people down, i just wanted to hear what you thought

[abrage22]

Hey for once Snakes is arguing with someone other than me, lol.