Rating the professionals

[Absolutely Adequate]

http://www.baseballhq.com/free/free040102.shtml

It's an interesting essay comparing a dozen projections from different websites to see who did the best. I'll assume that the author is somewhat biased towards himself, but it was an interesting read in any case.

[trevisc]

thanks man..this is interesting

[kentx12]

Intresting reading. Thanks

[GotowarMissAgnes]

Shandler's approach here is basically crap. The true measure is to compare all of your forecasts to all of someone else's forecasts. Cherry-picking as he does is a huge non-no.

Here's some better, though not perfect, comparisons:

http://premium.baseballprospectus.com/a ... cleid=2515

http://www.bballdeluxe.com/wworld_03/kenhitcompare.htm

http://www.bballdeluxe.com/wworld_03/kenpitcompare.htm

Be patient with those last two, they take a while to load.

http://baseballprimer.com/articles/mccr ... 09_0.shtml

http://baseballstuff.com/mccracken/prjctupd.html

http://www.baseballstuff.com/tangotiger ... inal2.html

http://www.baseballstuff.com/tangotiger ... Final.html

http://www.baseballprimer.com/studies/a ... 0214.shtml