A Fleshner Fantasy wrote:12 team 5x5 league, roto scoring.
SP- Marcum, Lincecum, Hill, Bailey, Sheets, J. Johnson, Zito, Gallardo
RP- K-rod, Ray, Hennessey, Broxton
As mentioned, your staff is young and unproven, and it's not really a surprise that they're inconsistent. Marcum, Lince, Gallardo, Bailey, Johnson ... on a given day they could pitch like a stud or a pitch like a dud. Zito has been inconsistent as well, though Sheets and Hill are solid. I'm not surprised that they're giving you some trouble.
RP looks good to me for a 12-team league though.
Look at mine please: viewtopic.php?t=302343