Projections for both
Aurilia= .279 avg, 18 hr, 68 rbi, 72 r, 2 sb
Lugo= .275 avg, 14 hr, 54 rbi, 66 r, 14 sb
Not much difference. I'd go with Lugo because he has a little more upside. I think everyone agrees at this point that Aurilia's 2001 numbers were an anomaly.