Help me Settle a Debate.

[OneLoveBoomer]

Which Fantasy OF is better? League settings (12 player, H2H): R HR RBI SB GIDP AVG OBP W L SV K GIDP ERA WHIP

A:
Holliday
Bay
Rios

-or-

B:
C. Lee
Ichiro
Abreu

[Pimp Sauce]

Since i really dont know what your looking for (hits, runs, etc..)
I would say team B...they seem more solid now that Abreau is heating up

[mattlo]

depends on context such as format and scoring. all else being equal I'd take A, but it's close.

right now, abreu looks to be heating up and he could have a huge 2nd half in that lineup; it's tough to say which group will be better for the remainder of this season

in a keeper league, A is definitely better because those guys are all at the beginning of their prime years, while B's players are all over 30.

if steals are important in your league, B has the edge there

[OneLoveBoomer]

I edited the above to include league settings.

[zechs]

Team A if you need help on HR & RBI, given the talent's upside
Team B if you need help on R, SB, OBP

[Sid Bream's Slide]

I'd say A is better right now, but I have a feeling B will be better come end of season, especially with Abreu starting to get on base a little more. "A" definitely seems to be more power oriented while "B" is more about speed.

I could use some help with a logjam I've got.
viewtopic.php?f=29&t=300569

[Leena]

Depends what the rest of your team is like...

I'd side towards Bay and Matthew, though. I still have my doubts that Abreu will keep this up.

[SJNez46]

I like team A better