Sizemore vs. Reyes

[Yoda]

Stats as of 9/21:
Reyes: 113 runs 10 hr 50 rbi 78 sb .288 ba

Sizemore: 115 runs 23 hr 74 rbi 33 sb .272 ba

With both batting leadoff, I guess you have to ask yourself, "are a few points in batting average and 45 stolen bases worth more than 13 homeruns and 24 rbi's." Personally, I'd rather have the steals.

I'd rather have the power.

[pokerplaya]

Stats as of 9/21:
Reyes: 113 runs 10 hr 50 rbi 78 sb .288 ba

Sizemore: 115 runs 23 hr 74 rbi 33 sb .272 ba

With both batting leadoff, I guess you have to ask yourself, "are a few points in batting average and 45 stolen bases worth more than 13 homeruns and 24 rbi's." Personally, I'd rather have the steals.

I'd rather have the power.

I'd definitely rather have the steals....and extra BA.

[Yoda]

Stats as of 9/21:
Reyes: 113 runs 10 hr 50 rbi 78 sb .288 ba

Sizemore: 115 runs 23 hr 74 rbi 33 sb .272 ba

With both batting leadoff, I guess you have to ask yourself, "are a few points in batting average and 45 stolen bases worth more than 13 homeruns and 24 rbi's." Personally, I'd rather have the steals.

I'd rather have the power.

I'd definitely rather have the steals....and extra BA.

That's a difference of 10 hits.

What is more relevant is OBP:
Sizemore = .385
Reyes = .361

And SLG:
Sizemore = .455
Reyes = .427

I would say those are far more important than the extra 10 hits.

[pokerplaya]

Are we talking fantasy or real life?

I assumed fantasy - so why does OBP make any difference at all? The assumption is obviously 5x5

[pokerplaya]

I'm almost positive he'll finish with at least 10, and likely at least 15.

The homerism is starting to squeak out I think.....I'll say 10 is his ceiling this year.

With just 10-11 games left this is coming down to the wire...

HA! He hit his 11th tonight, I WIN!!!

[J35J]

HA! He hit his 11th tonight, I WIN!!!

11th and 12th.......figures!

[Yoda]

HA! He hit his 11th tonight, I WIN!!!

11th and 12th.......figures!

Still pretty poor considering that most people picked him in the first round expecting he would hit 20+

[J35J]

HA! He hit his 11th tonight, I WIN!!!

11th and 12th.......figures!

Still pretty poor considering that most people picked him in the first round expecting he would hit 20+

I agree. My preseason rankings had him right at 12 HRs. I also had him down for a .286 avg in my preseason rankings!

viewtopic.php?t=244099&hilit=reyes