Do I make this trade??? Maggglio involved whir

[Legia13]

This is a 12 team h2h standard cats. I have a winning record in all the pitching cat and losing in most of the hitting ones. DO i make this trade?

I get: Magglio/Gorzelanny
I give: Cuddyer/Sabathia

C Bengie Molina
1B Ryan Howard
2B Ian Kinsler
3B Garrett Atkins
SS Miguel Tejada
OF Kevin Youkilis
OF Sammy Sosa
OF Ichiro Suzuki
Util Jim Thome
BN Michael Cuddyer


SP John Lackey
SP Justin Verlander
RP Francisco Rodríguez
RP Matt Capps
P Chad Cordero
P Jeremy Accardo
P Jon Garland
BN James Shields
BN Derek Lowe
BN C.C. Sabathia
BN Bronson Arroyo

[biju]

^^^ Awesome sig.

You're going to have much better luck in the "Draft, Trade, Keeper and Waivers Questions" forum. Most of the "forum police" will haunt you until the end of time if you post trade questions in here.



Me personally, I would have a hard time selling off Sabathia right now. Yeah, you're probably selling him high, but you're also buying Magglio high. You can afford the trade, but I think I might try to get a little more. Solid pitching is a pretty good commodity and just because you have a bunch doesn't mean you should give it away cheaply.

[Legia13]

Wow totally sorry for this, I'm gonna go ahead and report my own post because I accidentally posted it here.


p.s. thanks for the response anyway