Better Combo: Price/Porcello or Mcgee/Inman.....

[birdmandig]

based on long term potential

IS this as clear cut as I see it....leaning towards the PP side.

Opinions. Please and Thank You.

[J35J]

I'll take Price/Porcello easily!

[raiders_umpire]

Very close. I don't think Price or Porcello will come in as do as anywhere as good as McGee or Inman will do this year. As far as ceiling of the 4 guys, Porcello has the highest ceiling even though his low is the lowest of the 4 as well. I would rank McGee the 2nd highest ceiling. I would probably take McGee and Inman mainly because they are younger then Price and have been brought along a bit slower. Plus, I also don't think Price is the best college pitcher of the last 8 years or so like some scouts seem to think. He has alot of work to do with his changeup to ever even become a #3 in the majors much less this ace that could break the Devil Rays staff as soon as next summer.

[05worldserieschamps]

Upside? Price/Porcello hands down. But Inman/Mcgee are much safer. Depends on what you need...

[J35J]

Upside? Price/Porcello hands down. But Inman/Mcgee are much safer. Depends on what you need...

This is where I am comming from. He mentioned long term so I went with the higher upside pair.

[05worldserieschamps]

This is where I am comming from. He mentioned long term so I went with the higher upside pair.

Right, I would take Price/Porcello as well. But just because it's long term doesn't mean anything. Mcgee and Inman's chances of making the big leagues are both very good, and we all know how easy it is for pitchers(such as porcello and price) to fail having little or no sucess in professional baseball.