Trade Scenario Tourney:Round 1-theclefe vs. suppasonic

[Snakes Gould]

yeah the soriano scenario is unlikely and so is the giants adding 17 million more in payroll for abreu and thats if you even get the yankees to consider selling at the deadline.

[PlayingWithFire]

okay, won't do this silly stuff in the future.

[whoseyourdaddy12]

Can we do SF again? Seems like they were a really good team to use for something like this.

[jake_harv88]

Is suppasonic going to edit his post? He did a lot of the "well if i couldn't do this i would do this" kind of stuff. Nothing very definitive. Theclefe did a little bit of that but not as much. Not too mention clefe actually posted his lineup and rotation where as suppasonic didn't. I'll hold off on voting for little while, but if theres no edit then I definately go with clefe...

[PlayingWithFire]

Is suppasonic going to edit his post? He did a lot of the "well if i couldn't do this i would do this" kind of stuff. Nothing very definitive. Theclefe did a little bit of that but not as much. Not too mention clefe actually posted his lineup and rotation where as suppasonic didn't. I'll hold off on voting for little while, but if theres no edit then I definately go with clefe...

doubt he's editing it. just vote.

[Fantasy Man 27]

As a Braves fan, sorry Suppa, but that trade makes no sense at all. The bullpen blew so many leads for us last year, then we lose Gonzalez, now we trade the red hot Willie Harris who has been a spark plug and our COTF for a one-year wonder? Lowry certainly will improve, but I would much rather watch a different left named Matt Harrison start for us.

PWF, I like these, keep 'em coming!

[suppasonic]

I didn't edit my post because I dont think a problem like this could be solved with a single action or two, and it would be too hard to know trade value when a month has gone by that we dont know about. I would do what any manager would do, try different people until someone worked. I just listed the different ways I would get those people. Calling up Misch, making a trade, putting ortiz in the rotation and letting lincecum close; If I edited my post it would not be what I think would be the best way to handle things.

As for a line-up/pitching roster, this question was about the bullpen, so really that would be the only thing that needed to be listed. And I couldnt give you a final bullpen, because I dont know how these people would pitch.