Pettitte vs. Wolf

[TownDrunk]

If you had to choose, who would you pick?

[denvermax]

hmm, not sure on this one. probably wolf though.

[TownDrunk]

Neither am I. I'm in a keeper salary league. Pettitte is $12, while Wolf is only $2. However, I'd like to get/keep the best player.

[denvermax]

for that difference in value, you got to go with wolf

[kentx12]

for that difference in value, you got to go with wolf

I agree. I would put Pettitte slightly ahead of Wolf but for the price differance you gotta go with Wolf.

[Absolutely Adequate]

And I'd put Wolf ahead of Pettitte anyway. But at a $10 price difference, you could spend the money upgrading elsewhere.

[BigLebowski]

Wolf is better anyway so the savings of $10 is just gravy.

[rangrfan]

I'm thinking about keeping Wolf for my team....I'd go with Wolf.....he's only 27 and he has more upside. Not sure of what Phillies new park will be like pitching wise but I really like Wolf's WHIP, K's and ERA over Andy over the last 3 years.

Andy also is pitching in Minute Maid now as opposed to Yankee Stadium with a bigger outfield and the ball can really jump out of the park.

[TownDrunk]

Thanks for all your replies.

I went ahead and traded Pettitte for Wolf. The top 4 of my rotation is now Mussina, Beckett, Wolf, and Burnett. Not too shabby.

[trevisc]

good job!