I have seen trades not go thru because a player was taken off of the DL after the trade has been accepted. We had a thread in here this spring with some guy freaking out over the same thing. The only other reason why a trade wouldn't go thru would be because of a veto, and that would show up on the log for everybody to see.
I am surprised this is the first you know of this.
Most guys that I know that play Yahoo have just accepted this as a Yahoo quirk, and make any necessary transactions we need to in order to get around it, or just have the commish fix it after the fact.
- I'd never seen anyone express concern about the secnario described by the original poster (having an uninjured guy in your DL slot for the entire duration of a trade transaction). Probably because it doesn't actually cause problems.
- I am familiar with the different problems you're describing, because we believe we fixed them at the beginning of this season. I've posted that here a bunch of times, every time I see someone giving these warnings; I'm surprised this is the first you know of this
. Since we believe we fixed it, I haven't seen a confirmed case of a trade getting botched. It is entirely possible there is some other funky scenario we missed, and it can still happen, but I haven't had one confirmed case of this problem since we believe we fixed it.
If you, or anyone, thinks you have seen a trade fail to go through that should have, I'd encourage you to PM me with the details and I can try to investigate. But I think at this point, most or all of it is people reacting to things that were fixed long ago.
I'm going to actually get back to work now