Your Top 10 Pitchers of All-Time

[bigh0rt]

Really nice list ... I might squeeze in Bob Gibson and Nolan Ryan, but still, nice work.

Uhhhg!

I don't think Tavish likes Nolan!

With good reason, too. Now there's by and far, the most overrated pitcher in the history of the game.

[hot4tx]

Bobby Witt.

[Tavish]

Really nice list ... I might squeeze in Bob Gibson and Nolan Ryan, but still, nice work.

Uhhhg!

I don't think Tavish likes Nolan!

With good reason, too. Now there's by and far, the most overrated pitcher in the history of the game.

Gibson isn't far behind.

[bigh0rt]

Really nice list ... I might squeeze in Bob Gibson and Nolan Ryan, but still, nice work.

Uhhhg!

I don't think Tavish likes Nolan!

With good reason, too. Now there's by and far, the most overrated pitcher in the history of the game.

Gibson isn't far behind.

What are you some kinda racist 'er sum'in?

[bigh0rt]

1. Walter Johnson
2. Lefty Grove
3. Roger Clemens
4. Pete Alexander
5. Pedro Martinez
6. Christy Mathewson
7. Greg Maddux
8. Tom Seaver
9. Warren Spahn
10. Cy Young

I like this list better......

Yeah well you're not invited to my birthday party.

[Tavish]

With good reason, too. Now there's by and far, the most overrated pitcher in the history of the game.

Gibson isn't far behind.

What are you some kinda racist 'er sum'in?

At least I'm not a raging Mets homer. Seaver as the greatest ever? Is Gooden in the Top 15?

[NYCBuckeye]

Really nice list ... I might squeeze in Bob Gibson and Nolan Ryan, but still, nice work.

Uhhhg!

I don't think Tavish likes Nolan!

With good reason, too. Now there's by and far, the most overrated pitcher in the history of the game.

Granted, Nolan Ryan isn't my favorite pitcher by any means, but 324 career wins, 20 seasons of double-digit wins, 5,714 strikeouts, 3.57 ERA and 1.27 WHIP should at least put him into consideration, no?

[Barry25]

Really nice list ... I might squeeze in Bob Gibson and Nolan Ryan, but still, nice work.

Uhhhg!

I don't think Tavish likes Nolan!

With good reason, too. Now there's by and far, the most overrated pitcher in the history of the game.

Granted, Nolan Ryan isn't my favorite pitcher by any means, but 324 career wins, 20 seasons of double-digit wins, 5,714 strikeouts, 3.57 ERA and 1.27 WHIP should at least put him into consideration, no?

And how about the 7 No-hitters?

[Tavish]

With good reason, too. Now there's by and far, the most overrated pitcher in the history of the game.

Granted, Nolan Ryan isn't my favorite pitcher by any means, but 324 career wins, 20 seasons of double-digit wins, 5,714 strikeouts, 3.57 ERA and 1.27 WHIP should at least put him into consideration, no?

No, no, no.

[SteveJeltzPhanClub]

I think you guys are missing the true #1: Satchel Paige

My list:
#1 Satchel Paige
#2 Walter Johnson
#3 Roger Clemens
#4 Sandy Koufax
#5 Bob Gibson
#6 Lefty Grove
#7 Christy Mathewson
#8 Randy Johnson
#9 Cy Young
#10 Greg Maddux