Which of these two rosters is better for 5x5 Roto? - W H I R

[Heiserman02]

One is my roster before a possible trade and the other is it afterwards...I'm torn on a monster deal.10-Team 5x5 Mixed League

C - M.Barrett
1B - A.Pujols
2B - C.Utley
3B - R.Zimmerman
SS - C.Guillen
OF - J.Bay
OF - C.Crawford
OF - A.Rowand
UT - A.Gonzalez
Bench - P.Konerko
Bench - E.Renteria

SP - R.Oswalt
SP - C.Young
RP - H.Street
RP - P.Neshek
P - J.Maine
P - R.Hill
P - K.Escobar
Bench - J.Blanton
Bench - T.Lincecum
Bench - T.Gorzelanny
DL - F.Hernandez

or

10-Team 5x5 Mixed League

C - M.Barrett
1B - A.Gonzalez
2B - C.Utley
3B - R.Zimmerman
SS - C.Guillen
OF - M.Holliday
OF - C.Crawford
OF - J.Bay
UT - P.Konerko
Bench - A.Rowand
Bench - E.Renteria

SP - R.Hill
SP - C.Young
RP - H.Street
RP - J.Putz
P - J.Maine
P - P.Neshek
P - K.Escobar
Bench - J.Blanton
Bench - T.Lincecum
Bench - T.Gorzelanny
DL - F.Hernandez


I've got two hours to decide on this trade...WHIR, just post a link.

[dloke]

The second team seems worse off than the first except in relief pitching.

[knack]

i like team 1.

pujols shoudl come around, unless his leg problems are more serious than it seems.

and having roy to anchor the pitchign staff is much better. not to mention, team 1 has a.gonz who's going to be a breakout star this year. he's a great backup to have for pujols.

[Heiserman02]

well, they both have Gonzalez, the difference is on team B he's the starting 1B and on team A he's a UTIL...

on team A I'm actually more likely to try and sell high on him to pick up a reliever

[offpudding]

I don't like it at all. I think team A is better off, considering what it looks like the trade would be.

[Heiserman02]

well the trade is actually me getting Pujols/Oswalt for Holliday/Putz if people weren't sure...I guess I'm going to do it but i'm surprised that everyone is so sure about it...holliday is an absolute monster and the Cardinals offense has beeen pretty terrible this year

[nothingtoproveco]

I agree that team one is better. As much as I like Holliday, Pujols will turn it around and Oswalt is a great starter to have in your lineup. I'd say go for it...

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/foru ... p?t=286210