Hunter Pence or Billy Butler

[Members Only Jackets]

In one keeper, I traded Pence and got Butler.....in another (in which I had NO CF and OF depth) i traded Butler for Pence.

[raiders_umpire]

In one keeper, I traded Pence and got Butler.....in another (in which I had NO CF and OF depth) i traded Butler for Pence.

You done great in one, and got robbed in the other.

[Members Only Jackets]

raider--so u think Butler is that far better than Pence?

[J.C.Fighter]

Which player in the majors is Billy compared to or projected to be

[Members Only Jackets]

Which player in the majors is Billy compared to or projected to be

Travis Hafner



Now I'd like to know who Pence compares to....

[Yoda]

Which player in the majors is Billy compared to or projected to be

Pujols is one of his comps...

[scotty5150]

so u think Butler is that far better than Pence?

Without question.

[Shizane]

I need advice on these 2 for THIS YEAR ONLY (no option to keep either one). Who do you see putting up the best stats?

I posted it in another forum as well:
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=280089

[Members Only Jackets]

so u think Butler is that far better than Pence?

Without question.

who would u say is comparable to Pence... currently...

[frankadelic]

I need advice on these 2 for THIS YEAR ONLY (no option to keep either one). Who do you see putting up the best stats?

I posted it in another forum as well:
http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=280089

PECOTA gives Pence a higher VORP though Butler has a slightly higher upside, probably because of his youth.
The lower VORP on Butler is probably because of his defense, which is atrocious.

For THIS YEAR ONLY, Pence is probably a better pick.