Magglio vs. Jeter

[The Jury]

Mags for sure. As for that last post, do you think so? I'm pretyt sure Nomah is one of the best baseball players and just faded out of memory because of his injuries.

[ScurvyDog]

Maggs, Maggs and then Magglio ...

[smp2112]

In my mind with a 2nd round pick you have to go with the best talent available. In this case it would be Mags by a lot.

Jeter .297 18 - 75 - 32
Mags .320 38 - 135 - 7

All you give up is steals, RBI and homers are almost double. I think Jeters avg will bounce back up above .300 this year so I would say no major advantage for either there.

I would take Mags.

[trevisc]

Jeter

ok,ok..I was just kidding.

Maggs!

[UMTerp29]

You've got to pick the best available player here, not worry about position scarcity yet.....that said, Maggs is a stud.

[ironman]

I think this horse is dead my friends. Let me get one good kick in though. Go with Magglio!