Trade Involving CUtley for several of my prospects

[powenM]

It seems like a lot and deciding who to drop might be hard also.

I might be able to ask him to throw in Reed Johnson, Im not sure though.

He wants ESantana, TLinceum, BWood & FPie for Utley.

What do u think?

20Team Dynasty league

R HR RBI SB AVG OPS W SV K HLD ERA WHIP

My Team (Pls note there r 3 Utility starting positions also):

C Brian McCann, Chris Iannetta
1B James Loney N/A, Ryan Shealy
2B Ryan Freel
SS Édgar Rentería, Khalil Greene, BWood N/A
3B Álex Rodríguez
LF Termal Sledge, Alfredo Amezaga,Adam Lind N/A
CF Ryan Church, Félix Pié N/A
RF Álex Ríos

SP Jason Schmidt
Brandon Webb
Jeremy Sowers
Ervin Santana
Chris Young
HSanchez DL
Tim Lincecum N/A

RP Brad Lidge
Mike MacDougal
Alan Reyes
Pat Neshek
_________________

[whoseyourdaddy12]

no way I think thats a lot to give up


http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/foru ... p?t=270537

[nathan050904]

This is a hard trade to really evaluate. I don't know if I'd do it personally. I believe in a 20 team league good pitching is really hard to find and you'd be dealing Ervin and Tim. Utley is a great player at a weak position but, I think your giving up to much elite talent especially in a league of your size. I'd rather have the prospects and Ervin Santana to be honest especially in a 20 team league.

[raiders_umpire]

Bring on Utley to my team. I will take stud MLB players all day every day over prospects.

[bigken117]

Bring on Utley to my team. I will take stud MLB players all day every day over prospects.

Yes. Unless you're already playing for next year, this is a win for you.

[PlayingWithFire]

Bring on Utley to my team. I will take stud MLB players all day every day over prospects.

YEP!

[J35J]

Bring on Utley to my team. I will take stud MLB players all day every day over prospects.

YEP!

[raiders_umpire]

Bring on Utley to my team. I will take stud MLB players all day every day over prospects.

Yes. Unless you're already playing for next year, this is a win for you.

Even if I am playing for next year, I will gladly build my team around a stud 28 year old 2nd baseman.

[bigken117]

Bring on Utley to my team. I will take stud MLB players all day every day over prospects.

Yes. Unless you're already playing for next year, this is a win for you.

Even if I am playing for next year, I will gladly build my team around a stud 28 year old 2nd baseman.

Um yeah, I meant playing for 3 or 4 years down the line when those prospects should be contributors. And that there is no guarantee.

[thedude]

I'd do it. Erwin Santana could be good, but has done a lot yet. Lincecum is very good, but has injury questions (TINSTAPP), Wood has huge upside, but there are questions about his k rate and his batting average.

DO it.