Better this year... better overall?

[Niffoc4]

I know this is the wrong forum, but most of the guys have little major league experience. Who will be better this year, and who will be better in the future? I'll have an extra roster spot when Quentin goes on the DL
Elijah Dukes
Scott Hairston
Josh Hamilton
Jason Kubel

I'm leaning towards Dukes, but Kubel's the only one who should see PT all year, while Hairston will see the most PT early on.

[High Heater]

Kubel
Hamilton
Dukes


long term:

Dukes
Kubel
Hamilton

[ukjohn]

Hamilton will have the best year...for long term I would go with either Kubel or Hamilton