I like Arod/Bay/Berkman..maybe Pierre this year, and that's about it. Guillen and Nomar (maybe even thome) should be considered serious injury risks. Nomar at first just might be the weakest person you could put at that position, I'm sure you could do much better even if your agency pool is thin by grabbing a conor jackson type, same amount of upside, trade a declining average for power and rbis. Other problem on offense is martin, weeks, cain(maybe best of this list), zumaya, broxton, young, santana, hill and wainwright all lack serious experience and are unproven. Looks like you reached on two great closers, but can two closers get the 90 saves your team needs to be in the hunt if broxton and zumaya stay as is? I like lackey and young, but could see your team at a considerable loss for wins (no way ervin gets 16 again). Thats just my opinion, I had a team similar to this and it got me nowhere. Take care.
Baseball is reassuring. It makes me feel as if the world is not going to blow up. ~Sharon Olds, This Sporting Life, 1987