My 5 keepers were Pujols, Crawford, A Rod, Lee, and Felix... I won last year.
My pitching could completely fall apart, I agree, I'm rolling the dice. The thing I like about Cabrera and Perez is that we can't use our 6th and 7th pitchers, so I figure what's the point of drafting Lilly, Glavine, etc., when I can take these guys with huge upsides (albeit unlikely), and just drop them if they suck and play the scrap heap if need be. Tehy'll have no negative impact on my team if they suck except that I'll be a few weeks behind on FA pickups.