Please rate team and look at trade

[ibsuckssobad08]

This is my team in a 14 player draft...

C-McCann
1B-Laroche
2B-Roberts
3B-Arod
SS-Hanley
OF-Ichiro
OF-Huff
OF-Markakis
Util-Conor Jackson
BN-Kouzmanoff
BN-Gomes

SP-Smoltz
SP-Dice-k
Rp-Gagne
Rp-Lidge
P-Ervin Santana
P-Woody Williams
P-Kei Igawa
BN-David Weathers
BN-Otsuka


I am currently involved in talk to trade Smoltz, ichiro, McCann, and hanley for David Ortiz, Gary Sheffield and Michael Young.... also the trade can be David Ortiz and Sheffield for Ichiro Smoltz and Hanley... please analyze

[jfg]

H2H or roto?

Both of those trade offers are bad in my opinion no matter what format, but I wouldn't even think about trading Hanley and Ichiro in a roto league unless you are getting speed back.

[sleepyglow]

yeah you are taking a big hit in speed and you already have a good amount of power plus you are giving away your only proven stud pitcher, terrible deals

it would totally throw off the great balance you have going no way i touch either of these deals

[jruiss01]

i would stay away from that trade....i think you need to address the problem in your OF...ichiro is ok for an OF but he is specialized just for avg....you need a slugger OF in there

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/foru ... p?t=258183