Trading a Vet for unproven yet highly ranked prospects

[powenM]

Please Join the debate. U guys seem to know more about these kids then others.

But some think that im making a bad move!

Pls check it out and comment:

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/foru ... viewresult

[High Heater]

i'd absolutely do that deal... Mulder is plain garbage and Schmidt is getting old

[J35J]

I think it is a fine deal but I would definately try to get more before settling with this deal. Schmidt will be fine for the next couple years. Mulder is garbage though.

I'd first try to get more out of the deal even if you have to explore other teams. If this is the best you can do then I would very lightly lean towards doing it.

Either way is fine with me...... I'm kind of on the fence with it personally.

[powenM]

I think it is a fine deal but I would definately try to get more before settling with this deal. Schmidt will be fine for the next couple years. Mulder is garbage though.

I'd first try to get more out of the deal even if you have to explore other teams. If this is the best you can do then I would very lightly lean towards doing it.

Either way is fine with me...... I'm kind of on the fence with it personally.

This is exactly the thing holding me back on this deal.

I send: JSchmit & MMulder for CBillingsley & LHockeover

Lets face it most people are basing JS's value on the last couple of years. But heres the thing. He's now pitching in one of the best pitchers parks, winning team & way more run support.

I see his value only increasing & I probably could get more later.

Saying that this deal sounds tempting!


20Team Dynasty league

R HR RBI SB AVG OPS W SV K HLD ERA WHIP

My Team:

C Brian McCann, Chris Iannetta
1B James Loney, Ryan Shealy
2B Ryan Freel
SS Édgar Rentería, Khalil Greene, BWood
3B Álex Rodríguez
LF Scott Podsednik, Adam Lind
CF Curtis Granderson, Félix Pié
RF Álex Ríos, RChurch

SP Jason Schmidt, Brandon Webb, Jeremy Sowers, Ervin Santana, Mark Mulder, HSanchez
RP Brad Lidge, Mike MacDougal, Brandon League, Pat Neshek

[Humphrey]

interesting offer but i think you could do better
schmidt still has some good years in him...mulder maybe too