Micheal barrett is a nice top 7-8 catcher in a 12 team league
Konerko is a top 5-7 first baseman who I personally don't like but he was a good pick for you
Phillips might be 20/20 with .280 average type or 15/15 with .265-.270 average type. I expect closer to 20/20 but isn't completley proven yet
David Wright is David Wright, not sure what pick you got him at but good pick nevertheless
Your OF is old 38, 28, 34... Sheffield should be fine at least for a year or two but who knows with his temper and somewhat of an injury risk. You should be slightly worried about ibanez just because he has never hda the kind of power season he had this year. I still pencil him in for 20-90-.290 and a bunch of runs but who knows if he can still give 30-110-.300 like he did last year. Holliday is in his prime and is a great keeper pick to round out a big 4 in your offense ((atkins, holliday, wright, konerko))
Your pitching is unproven, I think C. Young has hit his ceiling, but is fine as a 5th starter. I have no idea in what round you got zambrano and smoltz and dice-k in all of this but good drafting is what I must say. I am one of those guys who thinks Dice-K is overrated but he still should be the 3rd best japanese player in the league for his position ((I have high hopes for Johjima being a top 5 catcher and ichiro a top 5 hitter compared to not thinking that Dice-K is a top 7-12 SP)) but he should still contribute an ERA hovering below 4 and some nice K numbers as a 4th starter and then Smoltz and Zambrano are 200 IP/200 K/15 W guys and Zambrano is still very young on an improving team.
I like the idea to punt saves here and go for K/9. Another good K/9 RP that, if he is available, I would pick up in your case is Scott Eyre ((10.1)) but you should have that stat in the bag already imo.
I don't mind you punting Svs and SB here because I think even though you start off at best winning 10-2 weekley I do beleive that you will win on average about 7-5 or so
Nice drafting and I think this team i top 3-4 material
Thanks to Alec03 for the awesome sig