I am in the exact same league you are describing. I am always ticked that someone chooses to keep three (this year its Pujols, Miggy & D. Wright). Then they get 2 picks b/f I get one. My keepers are Sizemore, Mauer, Papi, Abreu, & Oswalt. I'm happy with them, but obviously this guys has three prime keepers. I think people should be required to keep five players, and we are not. Maybe requiring a minimum keepers is the answer.