ML pick, please help ASAP

[JohnR]

I play in a league where every minor league player you own is yours FOREVER. They get "tagged" and carried over year after year with your other keepers until you either drop or trade them....

that said, in a system like that, who would you rather have on your team?

Travis Snider
Billy Rowell
Clayton Kershaw
Fernando Martinez
Jose Tabata

[High Heater]

you mean a "Dynasty league?"

and to answer your question Travis Snider... and its not even close for me.

[05worldserieschamps]

I like Kershaw. He is still a few years off, but when he does come up, he is going to be sick. Amazing stuff.

[Steve-o]

I rate them:

24 Fernando Martinez (2010 ETA)
25 Jose Tabata (2010 ETA)
26 Clayton Kershaw (2010 ETA)

47 Travis Snider (2009 ETA)

62 Billy Rowell (2009 ETA)

I try and stay away from arms that are that far away, so I would probably either take Martinez or Tabata. Martinez has not hit for a lot of power yet, but neither has Tabata. Of those two I prefer Martinez. I just think his bat develops a little better then Tabata.

[Bigball]

I like Fernando Martinez and Snider. Snider is young and has great upside.

Kershaw has great stuff and like Snider in a 88 BD and was signed out of HS.


If you need OF go with Snider or Martinez ii fyo need a pitcher go with Kershaw out they are not going to help you out for a few years.

[TurdFerguson]

I would take Kershaw.But if you don't wont a pitcher, for reasons stated above, take Snider.I think he has the most potential out of the hitters listed.

[Koby Schellenger]

Unless roster spots is a big concern, go with Martinez or Tabata. If you need someone to perform sooner, Kershaw or Snider might be better. Either way, they're all some time off.