What order would you rank these seven?

[audioboy]

Have the 1st and 5th pick in a minor league draft coming up in a few weeks. I see 7 prospects above all the rest, how would you choose from the following:

Cameron Maybin
Tim Lincecum
Evan Longoria
Jay Bruce
Yvonni Gallardo
Clayton Kershaw
Andrew McCutcheon

That's the order I would rank them, but I'm wondering if I wouldn't be bettergrabbing Lincecum at #1 and hope to get either Bruce or McCutcheon at #5.

Is the difference between Lincecum and Gallardo/Kershaw greater than the difference between Maybin and Bruce/McCutcheon?

thanks for any input

[thedude]

Maybin
Gallardo- a close third to Bailey and hughes
Bruce
Longoria
Lincecum
Kershaw

[TurdFerguson]

Have the 1st and 5th pick in a minor league draft coming up in a few weeks. I see 7 prospects above all the rest, how would you choose from the following:

Cameron Maybin
Tim Lincecum
Evan Longoria
Jay Bruce
Yvonni Gallardo
Clayton Kershaw
Andrew McCutcheon

That's the order I would rank them, but I'm wondering if I wouldn't be bettergrabbing Lincecum at #1 and hope to get either Bruce or McCutcheon at #5.

Is the difference between Lincecum and Gallardo/Kershaw greater than the difference between Maybin and Bruce/McCutcheon?

thanks for any input

You really cant go wrong between Bruce,Maybin,and McCutchen.I give the slight advantage to Lincecum over Gallardo.
Bruce
Maybin
Lincecum
Gallardo
McCutchen
Longoria
Kershaw

[High Heater]

Maybin

Bruce
McCutchen

Lincecum
Gallardo

Longoria
Kershaw

[05worldserieschamps]

Maybin

Linecum
Longoria
Bruce
Kershaw
Gallardo
McCutchen

[Koby Schellenger]

Maybin
Gallardo- a close third to Bailey and hughes
Bruce
Longoria
Lincecum
Kershaw

That's the order I would rank them with Bruce and Longoria being nearly interchangable depending on your major league roster.

[ukjohn]

Maybin
McCutchen
Bruce
Longoria
Gallardo
Kershaw
Linecum

[nathan050904]

Cameron Maybin
Tim Lincecum
Jay Bruce
Clayton Kershaw
Yovani Gallardo
Evan Longoria
Andrew McCutchen

[jwhands]

I would generally do bats over arms, but this is my list:

Cameron Maybin
Andrew McCutcheon
Jay Bruce
Tim Lincecum
Evan Longoria
Yvonni Gallardo
Clayton Kershaw

McCutcheon should be higher than Bruce based on his body and better chance at 5 cat status. Bruce may be a solid hitter, but he isn't the athlete Andrew is (and I feel both are on the same level in hitting).

[stealthdevil]

Maybin
McCutcheon
Gallardo
Bruce
Lincecum

Longoria
Kershaw