Here were my scarcity adjustments from the spreadsheet for my h2h 14 team 5x5 league with k/9 instead of k as a category and normal Yahoo positions (C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, 3OF, Util, 2SP, 2RP, 3P, 5Bench).
Catcher ReplacementValue = -6.19
SP ReplacementValue = -1.67
RP ReplacementValue = 2.43
SS ReplacementValue = 2.99
2B ReplacementValue = 3.34
OF ReplacementValue = 5.24
3B ReplacementValue = 5.57
1B/Util ReplacementValue = 6.48
Now this is replacement value. This doesn't speak to how the tiers break down. At second base for example Utley isn't valuable because of a poor second base replacement value - he's valuable because he's in a tier all by himself. Also keep in mind that my starting pitching replacement value is so low because we're a h2h league. The average team carries 6 starters so you're looking at the 85th best pitcher being your replacement level guy. That stings quite a bit.