Minor league draft

[Big Hurt CPOY 06]

How do you guys feel about these picks given the rounds they were drafted in?

Philip Hughes, P, NYY-1
Jay Bruce, OF Cin-2
Ryan Braun, 3B, Mil-3
Clayton Kershaw, SP, LAD-4
Clay Bucholtz, SP, Bos-5
Bryan LaHair, 1B, SEA-6

This is a 1st year keeper, 10 team league.

[High Heater]

i ended up taking Hughes @ 3 in our rookie draft this year over Bruce wondering if i made the right pick or not myself. the order they are in looks about right to me.

[bigboy1234]

How do you guys feel about these picks given the rounds they were drafted in?

Philip Hughes, P, NYY-1
Jay Bruce, OF Cin-2
Ryan Braun, 3B, Mil-3
Clayton Kershaw, SP, LAD-4
Clay Bucholtz, SP, Bos-5
Bryan LaHair, 1B, SEA-6

This is a 1st year keeper, 10 team league.

Hughes is a consensus top 5 prospect, and in my opinion the 3rd best prospect.
Bruce is a steal in the 2nd considering he's without a doubt a top 10 prospect.
Braun is also a great pick, he's a top 15 prospect, should have been gone by 2nd round.
Kershaw, potential stud, could be a top 10 prospect by the end of the year, another great pick.
Buchholz is an okay pick, probably could have gotten something better, but not that far off.
And the only bad pick Bryan LaHair who was a terrible pick, he's not even close to a top 100 prospect.

Pretty damn good draft condering your first 4 picks were all great.

[thedude]

Your first 5 rounds were very good. your picks in rounds 2,3, and 4 were all very good value. Buchholz was drafted right where he should be drafted. LeHair is not a very good prospect.

[Koby Schellenger]

I think Bucholz was ok. LaHair was horrible. There are easily 50 guys that are available in your league that are better than him. Drop him for someone else.
The first picks were great. Lots of talent but definitely some gambles that can pay off huge.