The Prospect Game

[jwhands]

Lee Smith

Chris Parmelee

[brewcrewreview.com]

Nick Johnson (hopefully without the injuries)



Wade Davis

[J35J]

...don't want to rain on anyones parade but you guys do realize that "maybe" a quarter of these guys will come close to living up to any of these expectations..... I just wouldn't want to lead any newbies on that all these guys are going to be great. In reality there will probably be more of these guys last only 2-3 years in the majors and flame out than actually become all-star type players.


...ok I'll shut up now.... continue on....

[thedude]

...don't want to rain on anyones parade but you guys do realize that "maybe" a quarter of these guys will come close to living up to any of these expectations..... I just wouldn't want to lead any newbies on that all these guys are going to be great. In reality there will probably be more of these guys last only 2-3 years in the majors and flame out than actually become all-star type players.


...ok I'll shut up now.... continue on....

Yeah i know. Most of these are best case senerios. Except the Mel Hall comparison. But that is how prospects are rated, on ceiling.

[PlayingWithFire]

...don't want to rain on anyones parade but you guys do realize that "maybe" a quarter of these guys will come close to living up to any of these expectations..... I just wouldn't want to lead any newbies on that all these guys are going to be great. In reality there will probably be more of these guys last only 2-3 years in the majors and flame out than actually become all-star type players.


...ok I'll shut up now.... continue on....

Yeah i know. Most of these are best case senerios. Except the Mel Hall comparison. But that is how prospects are rated, on ceiling.

now I feel stupid for saying Corey Patterson is the best case scenario for Maybin, I thought you were asking what I think he'll become

[brewcrewreview.com]

Wade Davis= Jon Lieber



Corey Hart=?