Dynasty Trade w. prospects

[burntfaceman]

I tried puytting this in the general forum but got no responses. Maybe it'll fair better here. It's kind of a 'tweener.

I've been offered CC Sabathia for my Chris B. Young (ARZ), Andrew Miller and Anthony Reyes.

16 team 5x5. My team is loaded with few holes to fill and lots of young studs/prospects in the wings. I have Beltran and Crawford in the OF, with Matt Kemp, Billy Butler and Quentin to back them up. And I have a solid staff without CC that becomes one of the best in the league with him. I also have Hughes, Adam Miller and Phil Humber in the minors.

I think Sabathia is poised for great things and I'm always trying to win now, so prospects are usually trade bait. That said, there are teams a little more poised than me this year, even with CC, so I can potentially stand to sit tight and see how these guys pan out.

I tend to think it's giving up a lot of unknowns for a known, but considering how high these guys are being regarded, am I giving up too much?

[jps715]

personally I think that is too much. Assuming one of the two pitchers becomes something decent your probably already ahead of the game. While CC is a player I really like, there's truly no telling that Reyes will have a worse year then him. Young is also a solid prospect who's value should increase by year end. I would stay stick with the 3 for now and maybe use 2 of them as trade bait to help you come playoff time.

[TurdFerguson]

I would counter wit Andrew Miller out of the deal.I'm not that high on Reyes.But its probably to much for CC.I'm a big fan of CC...If you can get CC for Reyes and Young, it would be a great deal for you.