Who wins this trade

[PlayingWithFire]

Angels send:
C Jeff Mathis................n/a
SS Erik Aybar..............n/a
SP Young-Il Jung..........n/a
3B Robb Quinlan...........$365,000 (2009)

Indians send:
C Victor Martinez...........$700,000 (2008)
SP Adam Miller..............n/a

Angels contending, Indians rebuilding I assume.

[KDOGG]

Angels hands down. Obviously we all know what Victor can do but Miller is a top 10 pitching prospect with #1 starter potential. The prospects the Angels gave up aren't even top 50 prospects IMO.

[TurdFerguson]

In a landslide, the Angels.I don't think its even fair.

[Steve-o]

In a landslide, the Angels.I don't think its even fair.

I agree. I am one of those only veto if collusion people, but I would look at some extenuating factors between the two trading partners. Brothers or father/son? Anything else fishing going on?

[ensanimal]

Angels, and it is not fair or close. I would suspect something almost.

[bigken117]

That's a terrible trade for the Indians.

[thedude]

Angels. And it isn't even close. They get the best two players.

[TurdFerguson]

I wouldn't even trade Victor straight up for those 4.Throwing Adam Miller on top of it is laughable.He's one of the best pitching prospects in the game and could become an ace.Something definitely needs to be said about the trade, or vetoed.

I also find it funny that two people actually voted for the Indian side.

[High Heater]

did this really need a poll?