Maybin or McCutchen

[Nails]

Which one do you think will make an impact first, and which one do you think will be the best long term option? Thanks.

[Archduke Chocula]

The Pirates OF is garbage except for Bay so I'd go with McCutchen to make an impact first. I like him long-term, too.

[ukjohn]

maybin has more potential and is the better prospect, but McCutchen is very good, and will probably get called up to the majors earlier than Cameron

[dcskater619]

maybin has more potential and is the better prospect, but McCutchen is very good, and will probably get called up to the majors earlier than Cameron

[Nails]

I was thinking the same thing, but Maybin's K's kind of scare me a little. I do think that McCutchen will get the call sooner for the same reasons, but I wonder what is potential looks like in terms of stats. The reports I have seen say is very fast, but he also has pop that could turn in to 20+ HR power in th majors.

[J35J]

maybin has more potential and is the better prospect, but McCutchen is very good, and will probably get called up to the majors earlier than Cameron

[Can O' Corn]

I think McCutcheon comes up first, but Maybin performs better in the long run.

[High Heater]

Maybin is a elite type prospect. McCutchen is super but he just doesnt have the same cieling as Maybin.

he'll make the show first tho...

[FrozenRopes]

McCutchen is a wayy better player.
Short term
Long term

believe it.

[High Heater]

McCutchen is a wayy better player.
Short term
Long term

believe it.

hilarious at best