Gordon/Homer/Garza for...please help

[Members Only Jackets]

Hi...Minor League heavy so I thought to ask here....

Keeper...16 team..we keep them all...points , non roto

I give:
-Homer Bailey
-A Gordon
-M Garza

I get:
-C Carpenter
-A Lind
-Clayton Kershaw

is it worth it?? Me? I kind of like it...but I'd be giving up some serious potential.

Varitek, Jason C
Thome, Jim 1B
Utley, Chase 2B
Blalock, Hank 3B
Tejada, Miguel SS
Iguchi, Tadahito MI
Delgado, Carlos 1B CI
Holliday, Matt OF
Bruce, Jay OF CIN
Quentin, Carlos OF
Crawford, Carl OF

**Pitchers
Cain, Matt SP
Capuano, Chris SP
Haren, Dan SP
Lowe, Derek SP
Penny, Brad SP
Rodriguez, Francisco RP

Reserve Batters
Gordon, Alex 3B
Longoria, Evan 3B
Tulowitzki, Troy SS
Butler, Billy OF
Upton, Justin SS
Montero, miguel C

**Reserve Pitchers

Bailey, Homer SP
Elbert, Scott SP
Gallardo, Yovani SP
Garza, Matt SP
Miller, Andrew M. SP
Pelfrey, Mike SP
Zumaya, Joel SP



WHIR

[thedude]

i am going to say no. Because Gordon has so much potenial. But the best case of either Baily or Garza is that they devolp into a chris carpenter (so you trade them for him if you can), do if it would be possible to do the trade with gordon, you make it.

[dclark0699]

I keep your team the way it is and dominate in year or so

[Koby Schellenger]

I would shy away from this one. You've got two excellent prospects in Homer Bailey and Alex Gordon who are both going to be in the big leagues this year in all likelihood. Garza will be there too and although he doesn't project to be as good as Bailey, he should still be an effective SP.

[nathan050904]

Clayton Kershaw=Homer Bailey
C Carpenter>M Garza

A Gordon>A Lind

*I believe Clayton Kershaw is the same kind of talent as Bailey. Although Bailey is closer and therefore is probably the better bet.

*Right now Carpenter is the better pitcher between him and Garza. However, no one really knows how good Garza can be.

*Alex Gordon is the superior prospect by a mile. There's no real comparison between the two.

I honestly think you have to keep what you have. I don't like this deal for you. I absolutely love Gordon's potential to be one of if not the best 3rd baseman over the next 5 years.

[Members Only Jackets]

thanks a lot for the replies! I really appreciate it...

I'll keep my team as is

[BillyButler's Butler]

thanks a lot for the replies! I really appreciate it...

I'll keep my team as is

Good choice